by Satish Kumar Bahri
skbahri1@yahoo.com
24 February 2011
skbahri1@yahoo.com
24 February 2011
Rank Pay Maj To Brigs
Gentlemen,
Last year I had written to Mr Moily on 16 May 10, asking him as to why the govt was contesting the SC order of 8 Mar 10 when his declared policy was to reduce litigation by the govt. When he did not reply for about four weeks I wrote a letter Mrs Sonia Gandhi on 14 Jun 10 (Justice For Services, att above) asking her why the govt was shirking its obligation to pay an amount to officers who had been defrauded by it.
.
Today, lo and behold, I received a reply from the JS (Pension) in reference to my letter to Mrs Gandhi, att above as Scan 0025. The letter makes me laugh as it is the usual bureaucratic attempt to obfuscate the issue. The same way this govt is trying to mislead the country on the various scams plagueing the country.
.
I plan replying this letter through the RM with a copy to the JS and Mrs Gandhi. Telling them that we are not thumb sucking babes who can be fooled by babuisms. I would request you all to give me ammunition to answer this typical babu's foolishness.
.
Regards
Lt Gen SK Bahri,
1st JSW Course
Former MGO
.
Justice And The Armed Forces: A Mirage
.
I am writing to you about a subject which is becoming a rather touchy one both with the Government and the defence services, including the ex servicemen. The UPA II has just finished patting itself on its back for what it has done during the past 12 months. But one area where it has faltered is the redressal of grievances of serving and retired soldiers of the three defence services.
.
The Services have been depended upon by the Nation for guarding it against both, external aggression and internal disorder. They have acquitted themselves well each time and have earned the respect of the nation. It is one organisation, which is looked upon in horror by the Nation if a misdemeanour by one of its members, is detected. Such aberrations not only make headlines but even the Services handle them like cancer, which need to be excised promptly.
.
Can any other government wing be compared with the defence services? The morning newspaper seems incomplete if there is no news about a few lapses in one of the government’s arms eg., corruption, custodial killing, crores of intelligence funds meant for fighting Maoists being siphoned off by DGPs , selling land at throwaway prices to cronies, excise duty being evaded, continued rape of a subordinate’s wife, children being molested by people who are supposed to protect them and civil servants amassing wealth beyond their known sources of income. I could not believe when the press informed us that in Burail Jail in Punjab, there is a barrack only for convicted policemen!! (The only jail where a special barrack may be reserved for Indian soldiers must be in Pakistan!!) The world organisations have recently graded our civil services as the most inefficient. But we cannot do anything about it.
.
The above is known to the Aam Admi, whose patience is running out. We should be prepared for the worst, as he knows what he deserves. We have created a Frankenstein in the form of the Maoist menace due to totally inadequate governance and, another monster is in the making. I guess the armed forces will be drafted once again, as they are being planned to deal with Frankenstein.
.
But what is the morale and thinking of the soldiers? The PM will get reassuring reports from the Service Chiefs, as they cannot say otherwise. But believe me, Mrs Gandhi, there is a feeling amongst the soldiers that while they are protecting a beautiful nation, it is being eaten away internally by termites. Will they be asked to jeopardise their lives once again to remedy a self-created problem? They feel used and are resentful. The reasons are not too far to see, if one has the intention to see.
.
After the 8 Mar 2010 judgement of the Supreme Court in favour of Defence Officers (who had been denied the benefit of Rank Pay in the 6th Pay Commission while fixing their emoluments), to set right a patently obvious fraud perpetrated on them by the bureaucracy, the government has filed an appeal against the implementation of the judgement. I then sent the attached email on 16 May 2010 to the Law Minister, Mr Veerappa Moily telling him that the action of the Government is against his own statement that the government should not be a persistent litigant. I, as is customary in todays government offices, have not received an acknowledgement so far. So it is possibly lying in the wastepaper basket next to his table or censored by his OSD, the bureaucratic representative who acts as the self appointed filter of “bad news” from the “master”!
.
The soldiers, serving and retired, are a disillusioned lot. After your assurance in Amritsar, inclusion in the Congress manifesto, declaration by the President in her opening speech to Parliament, statement of the Finance Minister in the Budget speech and the proclamation by the PM from the ramparts of Red Fort, One Rank One Pension (OROP) remains a mirage. Rubbing salt in the wounds, directions of the highest court in the land are being contested, only because they are in favour of soldiers. (The bureaucracy had also appealed repeatedly against the judgement of the Supreme Court in favour of Maj Gens in 2008). Imagine a Committee of Secretaries met to consider the Judgement and within a week (a record of sorts!) decided to appeal against it, as it was financially unviable. Can a fraud detected by the Supreme Court be wished away due to its financial cost? Do you think the soldiers will swallow all this, and accept it happily? If your advisors say so then they are the same who have landed our Country in this sorry state of affairs, be it in the North East or in the 400 odd districts, with many more on the verge of joining them, affected by Maoism. They are the ones who are putting the fear in the politicians that the Defence Forces will take over the country if they are not kept under their thumb. A disastrous presumption.
.
For the country’s sake, please do not push the soldiers over the precipice and make them behave like our huge police force, which wants a bribe for registering a FIR or a bureaucrat who does the same for putting his signatures on a piece of paper. Mrs Gandhi please look after the soldier, he is ironically defenceless in his own country.
.
Mrs Sonia Gandhi
.
Chairperson UPA
10 Janpath
New Delhi 110001
Copy to
Dr Manmohan Singh
Honourable Prime Minister
7 Race Course Road
New Delhi 110011
.
Mr AK Antony
Honourable Minister of Defence
9 Krishna Menon Marg
New Delhi 11011
.
Mr Veerappa Moily
Honourable Minister of Law and Justice
Ministry of Law & Justice
4th Floor, A Wing
Shastri Bhawan
New Delhi 110001
.
Not On Original
.
Admiral NK Verma PVSM, AVSM, ADC
Chairman Chiefs of Staff Committee
Chief of the Naval Staff
Naval HQ, South Block, DHQ PO
New Delhi 110011
.
General VK Singh PVSM, AVSM, YSM, ADC
Chief of the Army Staff
Army HQ, South Block, DHQ PO
New Delhi 110011
.
Air Chief Marshal PV Naik PVSM, VSM, ADC
Chief of the Air Staff
Air HQ, Vayu Bhavan
New Delhi 110011
Respected Gen Bahri,
ReplyDeleteGoing through your mail was indeed highly disappointing. It is beyond comprehension that your highly justified letter to the UPA Chairman in Jun 2010, received this misguiding and evasive reply from a lowly JS (Pensions) eight months later ie on 24 Feb 2011, which actually says it all, and clearly indicates the intentions of the Government towards the Veterans of this country, who sacrificed their comfort and every good thing of life for the sake of the country. It is a pity that inspite of all the efforts put in by the aggrieved veterans, each and every one in the Government is ignoring and keeping their eyes closed to the injustices perpetrated upon them.
I feel it is now futile to approach any Government body on the issue of OROP any more, as the likely outcome is quite visible from the letters being issued by the various authorities including the Defence Minister. The Grievances Commission ordered by the Honourable Supreme Court, seems to be fizzling out under the circumstances, without even seeing the light of the day. In any case it being only a recommendatory body, its rcommendations would have to cross the hurdle of bureaucracy and the results can be foreseen even now itself.
The silent protests being staged by the IESM by surrendering Medals or signing in blood have so far turned out to be non starters and have failed to move any one, including the Supreme Commander (who has been denying even a justified audience to our senior most of veterans)and in future also in my view, they are unlikely to get any favourable reponse fom any direction.
In my view therefore, the only remedy now appears to be to file a strong case with solid justifications in Supreme Court/High Court/AFT as feasible. With illustrious stalwarts like you, Lt Gen Vijay Oberoi, Lt Gen Raj Kadyan and many more of the likes, the option may be seriously considered and implemented if found acceptable.
With kindest regards.
Col LK Anand Retd